Green
Day is a band with no purpose and no message for their fans. They
just wanna rock! But is that enough? Sure, it worked out great for
Dee Snider and Twisted Sister, but
can Green Day survive into the year 2000 with just a handful of good
songs and a peppy attitude?
You decide.
Unpretentious, unpredictable, underappreciated, sometimes
underwhelming, but always a hoot, Green Day is the '90s punk equivalent
to, say, the J. Geils Band: good
pop songs, nice guys, no agenda, no politics, just a rollicking good
time. Or so it seems. But what about those of us who want a little more
from their rock and than three chords and an attitude? What about those
of us who want a little venom in their bite? Sure, Green Day is one of
the only bands from the early-'90s punk resurgence that's actually had
some staying power (anybody seen hide nor hair of the Offspring or Rancid lately? A
recent Kurt Cobain
sightings? Anyone? Anyone?), but that alone doesn't really make them a
great band.
Yet c'mon, who in their right minds wouldn't find the wacky,
no-frills antics of vocalist Billie Joe, drummer Tre Cool and bassist
Mike Dirnt to be nothing less than hilarious and super-keen? Well, me
for one, but that's besides the point. There are millions of young,
impressionable, brainwashed kids out there who need their fix of
powerpop punk just as much as us jaded old-timers. Don't they deserve a
group to hang onto, a group to call their own? Well, sure they do, and
Green Day is just the band for the job.
Bright, funny, yet seemingly calculated, over the phone lead
vocalist Billie Joe has all the right answers to all the wrong
questions. "We really try to push ourselves artistically as much we
possibly can," he says. "To make the best records we possibly
can and write the best songs."
After two albums on the ultra-hip indie label Lookout Records (1039/Smoothed Out Slappy
Hours and Kerplunk), and
three successful major-label albums on Reprise, Green Day have clearly
proven they're no flash-in-the-pan. "It's too late, we're not a
one-hit-wonder. We've already far surpassed anything we ever imagined
that we could possibly do. People are just stupid," says Billie
Joe. Yet, like legendary showman Rodney Dangerfield,
Green Day still get no respect. Hardcore punks call 'em sell-outs and
alternative rockers have moved on to the Next Big Thing, while the
credibility-damaging mainstream rock fans embrace them in droves. All
the while, pop critics around the world seem to be predicting their
demise.
Billie just shrugs, "I never really liked those people anyway
when I started getting into punk rock music. They can really kiss my ass
for all I care. They can say whatever they want, but they're getting
paid to say it so fuck 'em. I think that attitude about selling out in
the punk rock scene and the political side of it is needed. It keeps
people on their toes. If everybody agreed on everything it would be
really boring."
Green Day is the classic success story, complete with tons of
hard work and a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow. After going the
route of indie albums and van tours, the earnest threesome scored a deal
with Reprise and released their 1994 magnum opus Dookie, the album
that helped launch punk rock into the mainstream with the smash singles
"Long View," "When I Come Around" and "Basket
Case." As the album generated hit after hit, Green Day found
themselves in a precarious position: trying to hold onto their old fans
and indie credibility, while simultaneously trying to branch out, be
successful, and have hits. Not that they're all about the Benjamins.
"I just write my songs," Billie states plainly.
Since their
Dookie, the band has defied all critical logic. Every time Green
Day release an album, critics swear that it will flop, claiming that the
group was lucky with that last one, but this new disc is sure to sink
their ship. And every time, the critics are proven wrong. When Green
Day's second Reprise effort, Insomniac, failed
to stay in the top 20 as long as Dookie did, critics pointed
fingers and screamed, "See I told ya so!" Yet the infectious
single "Geek Stink Breath" just kept picking up steam and
getting airplay, and the album turned out to be a steady-selling hit.
When Green Day's latest album Nimrod was
released, naysayers then screamed, "Oh my God, there's a ballad
with acoustic guitar! They're dead meat!" Yet the album has become
a smash, and said ballad. "Good Riddance (Time Of Your Life),"
is turning out to be Green Day's biggest hit to date. In fact,
"Time Of Your Life" has become such a crossover smash, it's
been featured on a recent episode of the TV hospital drama ER and
in the much-ballyhooed final Seinfeld episode.
So how does Billie feel about lending out his melodious pieces
of art to the mainstream media? "I think that's okay," he
replies. Alright, but did he watch that heartbreaking episode of
ER? "I heard that it was going to be on, but I kinda
purposely didn't watch it because that show is too heavy for me and I
don't like having my evening filled with people dying of fucked-up
diseases, so it's cool. The kid dies and they play our song or whatever.
Look, these are my songs. I can do anything I damn well please with
them. And you don't like it then leave it. It's as easy as that. Start
your own thing. This is my thing. This is what I've done with it and
there's a certain amount of pride in invested in that...I would never
sell it to a commercial. I would never sell it to a Nike ad or for a
telephone company or something like that."
Fair enough. So what's the major difference between riding around in
the van versus flying a charter plane whilst eating caviar? Is Billie a
different person today than he was when he started out in this rat race?
"Ummm...I don't know. I think I'm probably a bit more wacked-out
now in some sort of ways. You sort of adapt. When everything was just
exploding and getting big, you're on the road so much you never get a
chance to sit around and analyze it. You just keep going and you come
back home and then all of a sudden things are different and people look
at you funny."
But what about what about all the great unsung, underpaid punk
bands? The ones that never have a big hit single? Don't they deserve to
reap some of the rewards for all of Green Day's...I mean...their
hard work? "I think it's pathetic if people sort of want something
or feel as if I owe them something. Everybody has their place and time
and I don't really feel bad for anybody. That's just how it is. I mean I
don't know why it happened to be my band, but you know...fuck off."
(A little testy, aren't we? Interesting...)
But wait a second! Aren't I being a little slanted in my portrayal
of Billie and the boys? Don't Green Day deserve the accolades of every
other hard-working American band? Yes they do, folks. The problem isn't
that they're successful, or that they've made money, or that they've
"sold out." The problem is that they have no mission. I don't
mean a mission like saving the whales or disarming the nukes, and no, I
don't mean that they have to have a purpose, because rocking hard is
purpose enough for most music-lovers. It's just that they're not putting
a new spin on anything. They're not challenging anyone or breaking down
any walls. What exactly is Green Day bringing to the table? Teen angst?
Well, they're not teens anymore, and we've got plenty of that anyway.
Shock value? No, Marilyn Manson and
Trent
Reznor have that pretty sewn up. A raucous stage show? Yeah, but do
you really fear for Green Day's lives when they play? I mean, they might
jump around a lot and break some teeth, but is anyone really scared of
these guys? Like really scared, like Iggy Pop-scared?
No. Green Day is a fun, upbeat little punk band, nothing more, nothing
less. What they lack in the element of surprise or danger, they make up
with cute little pop songs...but just barely.
But let's allow Billie Joe to have the last words. When asked
what, if any, message Green Day has for their fans, Billie replies,
"Click," and swiftly hangs up the phone.
There you go.